Well, we’ve been here nearly 4 months and during this time not once have we been to the theater or to a movie! Just now we took it in our heads to go and see the operetta “Hadgi Moorat.” But what’s the use! Tickets have all been sold 3 days ago already. Prices in the first row were 1,500 rubles. And a few days ago I walked to Rostov – in darkness and along a frost-covered road – to hear Beethoven’s 5th Symphony, conducted by Bichter. But what happened!? I bought a ticket in the 6th row for 315 r., sat down in my place, and suddenly the electricity went off!... The audience sat for a whole hour in pitch darkness and then got up and left, knocking their foreheads against all door-posts, crushing, pressing each other....There was not a single little kerosene lamp in the theatre and not an individual among the administration to come out and give the public some explanation. What an animal attitude toward the “free citizens” of the most advanced government in the world, which has brought PARADISE to the earth!
To demonstrate the justice of his viewpoint, as a materialist, Comrade Gerus (during a discussion) advanced the following deliberation: “We are” he said, “materialists; we do not consider the mind as something absolute and eternal, as something separate from the body. My mind, that is, myself, the entire I – and not only the brain, where the process of thinking takes place, but the whole I, from foot to the crown of the head. Cut off my head – and the brain of itself will stop working, i.e., thinking. With the destruction of my body, my mind too will be destroyed, just as it had begun to develop in my body according to known processes of growth. Mind and body are inseparable.”
Though I tried to inculcate into him how absurd such reasonings are, I naturally did not succeed. I explained to him the following: in the first place, the notion that the idealists think the mind to be something separate and alien to the body, is wrong. On the contrary, the idealists see the mind and body as a unity, and believe that all life’s evil is in the artificial separation of mind and body. That means that the idealist will agree with Comrade Gerus, that the mind is the entire I, from head to heel. But in this the Comrade falls into the pure materialistic limitation, since he understands in the idea “all I” only one’s own skeleton, muscles, and nerves. But this is not enough. How can he be a worshipper of the “historical method” when he looks upon himself with such narrow mindedness? – What is an individual - an individual body and an individual mind? - -The individual body contains particles of millions of bodies that existed beforehand. The point of his development is the moment in the development of millions of individuals beginning from father and mother and going back to the first man, even still farther, to other more primitive forms of organic life on earth, and farther still to those material beginnings from which were created in the cosmic space the earth, further still...to infinity, in other words, my mind and I are one, as an organism, and both undivided go back to infinity, meaning that mind (Spirit) is infinity, not any matter, but an ideal, because eternity can be understood only as an idea. All these ready phrases and arguments of our household materialists are in themselves of little interest. But it would be interesting to bring to the surface and reveal the reason why they are so stubbornly repeating over and over and with such religious zeal their materialistic doctrine, that has been presented to them by someone, as the beginning of wisdom, from which they are to start their own “dance,” like starting over “from the corner of the stove” (Russian saying).
The Jews count the beginning of their era, from the imaginary beginning of the world, something like four thousand years ago, I believe. The Christians – from the establishment of Christ’s New Testament. The Communists – from the time of the Communist Manifesto, in 1848, and all wisdom on which their faith is built was given by Marx and begins with Marx. They look upon all else with contempt and disbelief. Because it is said (mistakenly said) that Marx and his assistants, as well as his nearest forerunners (Feierbach) have, so to say, established a new world outlook – a materialistic one. That is their philosophic justification for the revolutionary overthrow of the capitalistic order and installation of Communism. But Marx is only the creator of the theory. While they – our comrades, are the first to embody this theory into life, to continue and complete this idea of Marx. How is one, then, to avoid materialism?